top of page
Search

The Evolution Brief | May 2026

Writer: Melissa Sodano
Melissa Sodano
Apr 30
5 min read

Questions on Ethics – from a highschooler

Last week, my 16-year-old nephew, Charlie, asked me if he could interview me for a paper he’s writing for school.

He’s a junior in high school, and the assignment was to interview someone who has to make tough, ethical decisions at work.

He chose me. 🙂

I was really impressed by the thoughtful questions he chose – and it made me realize that employees (and you!) probably have these questions too. 

I also think we do not talk openly enough about this side of HR.  It’s complex work.  My approach is that there should always be a thoughtful, fair and consistent approach to how decisions get made.

One of the questions Charlie asked me was whether I had ever been asked to make a decision that conflicted with my own beliefs.

What I’ve learned over time is that even very difficult people decisions become much easier to stand behind when you know the process was fair and consistent.  That is a huge part of the responsibility of HR.

A very common example is when a manager comes to HR and says, “I want to fire this employee.” An HR person who is inexperienced, hesitant to challenge the situation, or too focused on speed may simply move the process forward. A strong HR person slows the conversation down and starts asking more questions.

·         Have expectations actually been made clear to the employee?

·         Has direct feedback been given?

·         Have coaching and development opportunities truly been exhausted?

·         Is this actually a performance issue, or is something else contributing to the situation?

·         And if it is performance-related, have we followed a fair and consistent process with this employee in the same way we would for others?

To me, that is where ethics shows up in HR work.

It is not just about the final outcome or whether someone ultimately stays or leaves the company. It is about whether the process itself was something you can stand behind, and whether people were given clarity, feedback, opportunity, and dignity throughout it.

Once those things are in place, difficult decisions become much easier to stand behind.

He also asked whether, when making difficult decisions, I felt like I actually had a choice.

The honest answer is that sometimes you do, and sometimes your influence is more limited than you would like it to be.

There are real situations where decisions have already been heavily influenced before HR is brought in. Sometimes there are financial realities, timing pressures, or leadership dynamics that narrow what options are realistically on the table.

What I have learned over time, though, is that strong HR leadership is not about controlling every outcome. It is about using your voice responsibly, asking difficult questions, and consistently advocating for fair and thoughtful processes, even when those conversations are uncomfortable.

I also think this is one of the reasons it matters so much to work for leaders and organizations that genuinely value those principles.

HR can only be effective when leadership is willing to engage thoughtfully, slow down when needed, and make decisions consistently. In the healthiest organizations, HR is not treated as an administrative function that simply processes decisions after the fact. It is treated as a strategic partner that helps leaders think more critically, responsibly, and consistently about people decisions before they are made.

Over time, I have become much more intentional about the kinds of leaders and environments I want to work with. The best leaders are not necessarily the ones who avoid difficult decisions. They are the ones who are willing to approach those decisions thoughtfully, listen to feedback, and stay grounded in fairness and consistency even under pressure.

He then asked how companies balance profit with what employees need.

There are certainly moments where business pressures and employee needs can feel at odds with each other, particularly during periods of rapid growth, financial pressure, restructuring, or change. But I do not think the answer is choosing one over the other, and in my experience, the strongest companies do not view employee needs and business outcomes as competing priorities.

In fact, many of the things employees need most are also the things that create healthier and more effective organizations. Clear expectations, fair and consistent leadership, strong communication, trust in decision-making, and a sense of stability all contribute to stronger performance, lower turnover, and healthier cultures overall.

A big part of HR’s role is listening closely enough to understand what employees actually need rather than making assumptions. Fair compensation is important and should absolutely be table stakes, but beyond that, companies should also be asking broader questions about the population they are supporting.

·         What stage of life are employees in?

·         What challenges are they balancing outside of work?

·         What types of support, flexibility, structure, or benefits would actually improve their experience in a meaningful way?

Sometimes the answers are expensive, but often they are not. In many cases, relatively thoughtful adjustments can create a significant impact on engagement, retention, and overall employee experience.

Where companies tend to struggle is when decisions are made too quickly, inconsistently, or without fully thinking through the impact on people and teams over time. Short-term thinking can create much bigger long-term problems.

He also asked if, looking back, there are situations I would have handled differently.

Absolutely yes.  Anyone who has worked in HR or leadership long enough would say the same thing.

With experience, you become better at recognizing nuance, better at spotting gaps in process, and better at trusting your instincts when something does not feel quite right.

Earlier in my career, there were times when I gave leaders too much benefit of the doubt. I assumed difficult situations had been handled more thoughtfully or consistently than they actually had, or I moved too quickly instead of slowing down and asking more questions before moving something forward.

Over time, I have become much more comfortable pausing, challenging assumptions, and digging deeper when needed. I have learned that if something feels off, there is usually a reason worth exploring further.

That does not mean decisions become easier. In many ways, the longer you do this work, the more seriously you understand the weight of people decisions and the impact they can have on someone’s career, financial stability, confidence, and overall well-being.

But it does reinforce the importance of slowing down enough to make sure decisions are being handled thoughtfully and responsibly, because once certain decisions are made, you cannot simply undo them later.

In HR and leadership, there is often so much focus on outcomes, execution, timelines, and moving quickly that we do not always pause to talk about the thought process behind difficult decisions or the responsibility that comes with making them.

These decisions matter deeply because they affect real people, real careers, and real lives.

I also found myself genuinely encouraged that Charlie was thinking critically about questions like fairness, ethics, leadership, accountability, and responsibility at work. Those are conversations worth continuing to have, and I left the interview feeling very optimistic about the thoughtfulness of the next generation entering the workforce.

 
 

Recent Posts

See All
Lady Gaga just became CEO of Haus Labs.

Lady Gaga just became CEO of Haus Labs. And while everyone is talking about what this means for the brand, I'm thinking about something else: The conversations her People & Culture team must be having

 
 
You Can't Outsource Difficult Conversations

You can't outsource a difficult conversation. But you can get help with them, and they DO get easier. I spoke with a CEO recently who had been frustrated with an employee's performance for over a year

 
 
The Evolution Brief | October 2026

Your People Strategy Shouldn’t Be Playing Catch-Up with Your Business Strategy Growing beauty and wellness brands have endless ambition. There’s always another launch, another market, another retail p

 
 

2026 © Copyright by Evolution Consulting, LLC. All rights reserved.

bottom of page