The Evolution Brief | April 2026
We’ve normalized reactive HR, and it’s holding companies back.
I hear a version of the same thing in almost every conversation I have and every company I support, whether it’s with a founder, an operator, or someone leading HR internally.
“Our HR is a mess right now.”
Usually, it’s said as if it’s something unique to their company, with an underlying assumption that other organizations have figured it out more effectively.
The reality is, it’s not unique at all.
Across companies of all sizes and stages, I see the same patterns repeat themselves:
• Processes that are largely reactive
• Communication that varies depending on the moment
• Managers who are doing their best but have never been given real clarity on what good looks like
• Candidates who have inconsistent experiences depending on how busy the team is that week
The problem is that this has become the norm.
And that is what is most striking to me, because it doesn’t have to be this way. It shouldn’t be this way, especially when it directly holds your business back.
Many organizations have accepted a level of inconsistency in how they operate their people function. It gets deprioritized in favor of more immediate business needs, and over time, what was once a temporary gap becomes the way things run. It works well enough in the early stages, so it continues, even as the business grows more complex.
Until it doesn’t.
What feels manageable at one stage starts to break under pressure. Growth exposes the gaps. Expansion requires a level of consistency that does not exist. And when a company is preparing for diligence or thinking about a potential exit, those same gaps become much more visible, very quickly.
I have seen both sides of this.
When I was Head of Global HR at Paula’s Choice, our approach was not about building something perfect. It was about building something intentional. We made a deliberate shift away from reacting to issues as they surfaced and instead focused on defining how we wanted the organization to operate as it scaled. We invested in clarity around roles, expectations, decision making, and manager capability. We built consistency into how managers led their teams and how employees experienced the company.
That foundation enabled us to scale, navigate acquisition, and maintain strong employee engagement along the way.
In my 25 years in HR, I have found that the gap between where most organizations are and where they need to be is often merely requires a shift in how HR is positioned and how the work is approached.
If you want to start shifting this today, focus here:
1. Get out of reactive mode: Take one area that is consistently messy, whether it is hiring, onboarding, or performance conversations, and define how it should work going forward. Even a simple, clear structure creates immediate lift.
2. Decide what actually matters right now: HR often becomes a long list of “we should fix this.” Narrow it down. What are the two or three things that will have the biggest impact on your team this quarter? Start there.
3. Create consistency where it does not exist: Consistent 1:1s. Clear expectations for managers. Defined communication rhythms. It is not complicated, but it is powerful.
You do not need to be perfect. Most organizations are not.
But there is a meaningful difference between operating in a way that is common and operating in a way that is intentional.
The companies that scale well, expand effectively, and become truly valuable are not necessarily doing more than everyone else. They have simply made the decision not to operate like everyone else.
P.S. If you’re working through some of this right now, I’m always happy to compare notes.
